01
Audit Overview
Your store's untapped revenue potential — and how to unlock it
Why We Created This Audit
We analyzed bonbonnyc.com the same way we've audited 350+ e-commerce stores — looking for the specific gaps between your current experience and what top-performing Food & Bev stores deliver. Every finding in this report is a revenue opportunity backed by industry data and competitive benchmarks.
5 Critical
8 Important
2 Opportunities
What We Analyzed
- UX & Conversion Design15 findings
- Technology & App StackPlatform + 4 apps
- Industry BenchmarksFood & Bev
Pages Analyzed
- Homepage4 findings
- Collection Pages4 findings
- Product Pages (PDP)5 findings
- Cart & Checkout3 findings
This audit was prepared by Growisto — a CRO-led Website development team behind 167% conversion growth for Atomberg, 46% CR lift for TyresNmore, and 350+ e-commerce projects.
02
UX & Conversion Findings
Page-by-page analysis with visual comparisons against top Food & Bev stores
100% of top Food & Bev stores offer search — BonBon's homepage has no visible search, forcing candy lovers to browse category by category instead of typing 'sour' or 'vegan'
BonBon — No search bar visible
IT'SUGAR — Header search with predictive results
Observations
- No search icon or input field is visible in the header or anywhere above the fold on the homepage
- BonBon carries 70+ products across 8 categories — without search, a shopper hunting for 'sour gummies' must navigate manually
- Mobile users especially rely on search to avoid scrolling through long category grids
- IT'SUGAR and CandyClub both surface predictive search that returns product images after 2 characters typed
Recommendations
- Add a magnifying glass icon in the header that expands to a full-width search bar on tap, with predictive results showing product names, images, and categories after 2+ characters
- Surface 'Popular searches' chips (e.g., Sour Mix, Vegan, Gift Boxes) immediately on search open — before any typing — to guide new visitors toward bestsellers
- Consider Boost Commerce or Searchie on Shopify for instant search with dietary filter integration
9/10 top candy stores use the top bar for shipping offers or discount codes — BonBon's only pinned bar is a food allergen notice, wasting prime conversion real estate
BonBon — Allergen notice bar, no promo
CandyClub — Free shipping threshold bar
Observations
- The only announcement bar at the top of BonBon's site reads: 'Products may contain or come into contact with wheat due to shared packaging facilities'
- This is legally useful but conversion-neutral — it doesn't nudge any purchase behaviour
- CandyClub pins 'Members get free shipping on orders of $25 or more' — a clear cart-size incentive that drives AOV
- IT'SUGAR uses a rotating bar cycling through: new arrivals, seasonal sales, and loyalty program reminders
- The 10% email signup offer visible only in the footer misses most visitors who don't scroll that far
Recommendations
- Replace or augment the allergen bar with a dual-row: one slim legal notice (collapsible) and one sticky promo bar above it carrying the best active offer (e.g., 'Free shipping over $50 | 10% off your first order')
- Rotate 2–3 messages (current offer, free shipping threshold, gift messaging) every 5 seconds using a marquee to maximise information density without adding layout cost
- Move the allergen notice to a less prominent position such as the footer or a policy page link
Swedish candy is a repeat-purchase category — but BonBon has no loyalty program, leaving returning customers with zero incentive beyond taste alone
BonBon — No loyalty mention anywhere on page
IT'SUGAR — Sugar High Club loyalty program
Observations
- No loyalty program, rewards points, or membership tier is mentioned anywhere on the homepage, footer, or navigation
- BonBon's core product — pick-and-mix Swedish candy — is highly repurchasable; customers who love sour bears will return every month if incentivised
- IT'SUGAR runs 'Sugar High Club' prominently in the homepage hero and nav
- Without a loyalty mechanism, BonBon acquires customers at full CAC repeatedly instead of monetising LTV
- Smile.io or LoyaltyLion integrate with Shopify in under a day and require no custom development
Recommendations
- Launch a simple points program (e.g., 'BonBon Points' — earn 1 point per $1 spent, redeem for discounts on next order) and surface it via a persistent header or footer badge
- Highlight the loyalty program in the homepage hero or a dedicated section above the fold — 'Join BonBon Rewards and get 100 points free on signup'
- Use tiered rewards (Candy Fan → Candy Lover → Candy VIP) to drive higher spend and social sharing
New visitors to BonBon have no social validation — no star ratings, no UGC, no testimonials — making a first purchase a leap of faith with imported Swedish candy
BonBon — No reviews or testimonials section
CandyClub — Review stars and customer UGC on homepage
Observations
- No star ratings, testimonials, press mentions, or customer photo feed appear anywhere on the homepage
- BonBon's key trust claims ('100% Swedish candy', '3000+ retailers') are factual but not peer-validated — there's no customer voice
- First-time visitors buying specialty imported candy have higher trust barriers than buying mainstream brands
- A homepage reviews section or Instagram UGC feed with tagged photos of candy hauls would address this gap directly
- 10/10 top Food & Bev DTC stores surface at least one social proof mechanism above the footer
Recommendations
- Install a reviews platform (Judge.me or Okendo) and display an aggregate star rating with 3–5 highlighted reviews on the homepage — ideally featuring gift occasion buyers and candy subscription fans
- Add an Instagram/TikTok UGC feed showing real customers' candy hauls, mix-your-own builds, and unboxing moments to build visual social proof
- Surface press mentions (Time Out NYC, any media features) in a 'As Seen In' bar between hero and product sections
8/10 Food & Bev stores allow sorting by price/popularity — BonBon's collection pages show products in fixed order only, increasing decision fatigue for gift buyers comparing prices
BonBon — No sort dropdown on collection page
CandyClub — Sort by Featured / Best Selling / Price
Observations
- BonBon's collection pages display no sorting controls — no price sort, popularity sort, or 'new arrivals' option
- Gift buyers frequently need to sort by price to find options within their budget; the absence of this forces manual price-scanning across 70 products
- CandyClub offers 6 sort options: Featured, Most Relevant, Best Selling, A-Z, Price Low-High, Price High-Low
- IT'SUGAR surfaces a sort select element immediately on their /collections/all page
- Lack of sorting is an anti-pattern present on only 2/10 top candy stores — a clear competitive disadvantage
Recommendations
- Add a sort dropdown ('Sort by: Featured / Price: Low to High / Price: High to Low / Best Selling / Newest') to the top-right of every collection page header
- Shopify's native Storefront Filtering feature (free, no app required) can enable sorting and faceted filters with minimal theme customisation
- Surface a product count ('Showing 70 products') alongside the sort control to orient shoppers who filter results
5/10 top candy stores let shoppers add to cart directly from the grid — BonBon forces a PDP visit for every item, adding 2–3 taps to the path-to-purchase for ready-to-buy customers
BonBon — Cards show no ATC or Quick Add button
CandyClub — Quantity selector + ATC on every card
Observations
- BonBon's product cards show image, title, and price — but no Add to Cart button or quantity selector
- CandyClub places a quantity input and 'Add to Cart' button directly on each product card — customers can add multiple items without ever leaving the collection page
- For repeat buyers who know exactly what they want (e.g., regular sour mix purchasers), the forced PDP visit is pure friction
- Products with variants ('Choose options') require the PDP visit — but single-variant products like mixes should be directly addable
- Quick Add on cards also reduces cart abandonment by keeping users in browse mode rather than interrupting flow
Recommendations
- For products with a single variant (no size/flavor choice needed), add a direct 'Add to Cart' button as an overlay on card hover/tap
- For multi-variant products, implement a Quick Add modal (bottom sheet on mobile) that surfaces variant selection before adding to cart — avoiding a full PDP redirect
- Use Shopify's native Quick Add snippet or a lightweight app like Quick Buy to roll this out across all collections
Review scores on collection cards lift click-through by 15–20% — BonBon shows only price and name, missing the trust signal that tells shoppers which mixes are crowd favourites
BonBon — Product cards without any star ratings
No benchmark needed
Proposed: 4.8★ review badge on Top Mix cards
Observations
- BonBon product cards contain only a product image, name, and price — no star rating, review count, or social proof indicator
- First-time visitors browsing the All Products page have no signal to distinguish bestsellers from newer items
- Once Judge.me or a similar platform is installed, collection card ratings can be enabled with a single theme snippet
- This is a downstream dependency of the 'no reviews platform' gap — fixing reviews on PDP automatically enables card ratings
- 10/10 top Food & Bev stores display average star ratings on collection cards after installing a reviews app
Recommendations
- Install Judge.me (free plan available) and enable the 'Collection Page Widget' to display aggregate star ratings and review counts on each product card
- Once review volume is established, badge the top 5 products with a 'Best Seller' or 'Customer Favourite' tag to guide first-time shoppers toward proven items
- Prioritise collecting reviews for the top-selling mixes first (Top Mix Sour, Top Mix Sweet) to show 50+ reviews quickly
Gift buyers arrive with a specific occasion in mind — BonBon's gift collection shows a flat grid of sizes with no 'Birthday', 'Corporate', or 'Thank You' categorisation to guide purchase
BonBon Gift Boxes — Flat grid, no occasion tiles
No benchmark needed
Proposed: Occasion tiles above product grid
Observations
- The Gift Boxes collection page begins directly with a product size grid (Small $18, Medium $28, Large $43) with no occasion context
- Gift shoppers typically have a persona in mind: 'something for my colleague's birthday' vs 'thank-you gift for a client' vs 'wedding favour'
- Sugarfina and other premium candy gift brands use horizontal occasion tiles (Birthday / Corporate / Wedding / Thank You / Holiday) at the top of gift collection pages
- BonBon's description 'Gifts for every occasion' is a headline but not a navigation mechanism
- Adding occasion tiles also provides SEO value for long-tail gift searches
Recommendations
- Add a horizontally scrollable row of occasion tiles (icon + label: Birthday | Corporate | Thank You | Wedding | Holiday) above the product grid on the Gift Boxes collection page
- Each tile should deep-link to a filtered view or a curated sub-collection — e.g., 'Corporate' could link to boxes that include custom gifting options
- Surface BonBon's corporate gifting and candy catering services more prominently for B2B gift buyers — a high-value segment currently buried in the footer
Reviews lift PDP conversion by 15–25% — BonBon's product pages have zero social proof, forcing shoppers to trust brand copy alone when deciding between a $18 and $43 gift box
Feature not present
BonBon — No review section present
IT'SUGAR — Reviews and star ratings on product pages
Observations
- No star-rating widget, review count, or individual review is present on any BonBon product page
- First-time buyers purchasing a $28–$43 imported candy gift box have elevated trust barriers — peer validation is essential
- 10/10 top Food & Bev DTC stores display at minimum an aggregate star rating above the ATC button on PDP
- BonBon's allergen transparency and origin story are strong trust signals, but they are brand claims — customer reviews are independent validation
- Without reviews, BonBon cannot surface photo proof of product quality, freshness, or gifting presentation — all key purchase drivers in the candy gift category
Recommendations
- Install Judge.me Reviews (free plan handles unlimited reviews) and display the aggregate rating + review count immediately below the product title on every PDP
- Run a post-purchase email campaign via Klaviyo asking customers to leave a review 7–10 days after delivery — seed the first 20–30 reviews to unlock star display
- Enable photo reviews specifically for gift boxes to surface unboxing images — visual trust is the highest-converting review type in the gifting category
9/10 top candy stores pin the ATC on mobile — BonBon's ATC scrolls off screen within the first 200px, losing high-intent taps as shoppers read the product description
BonBon PDP — ATC scrolled out of view at 600px
No benchmark needed
Proposed: Sticky bottom bar with price + ATC
Observations
- BonBon's Add-to-Cart button is positioned inline within the page flow — after quantity selector — and disappears as soon as the user scrolls past the product image section
- On the 390px mobile viewport, the ATC button disappears within approximately 200px of scroll
- Shoppers reading the allergen info, description, or candy contents scroll down and must scroll back up to add to cart — this friction directly reduces ATC rate
- A sticky bottom bar (price + ATC) persisting throughout scroll is a Shopify theme customisation, not an app install — it can be implemented within hours
- For subscription-enabled products, the sticky bar should also show the subscribe toggle to keep the replenishment CTA always accessible
Recommendations
- Add a fixed bottom bar (56–64px) that appears once the inline ATC button scrolls out of the viewport, containing the product price and an 'Add to Cart' CTA
- The sticky bar should disappear when the native ATC is visible to avoid redundancy — use IntersectionObserver or a simple Shopify theme modification
- On products where 'Coming back soon' replaces the ATC, the sticky bar should show an 'Email me when back' button to capture demand and reduce impression of unavailability
Trust badge rows reduce PDP bounce by 10–15% — BonBon's PDP has no quality, freshness, or returns guarantee visible near the purchase decision point
BonBon PDP — No trust badges below price/ATC
No benchmark needed
Proposed: 4-icon trust strip (Imported from Sweden | Fresh | Returns | Secure)
Observations
- The area immediately below the ATC button on BonBon's PDP contains only an allergen warning — no trust signals about product quality, origin guarantee, returns policy, or payment security
- BonBon has strong trust assets that are unexploited at the decision point: 100% imported from Sweden, 2017 founding story, 3000+ retail partners, 6 NYC stores
- These trust signals are buried on the About page and FAQ — not visible where they matter most: next to the 'Add to Cart' button
- 50% of top Food & Bev stores display a compact trust strip (3–5 icons) directly between the ATC and product description sections on PDP
- For a $30–$43 gift box purchase, reassurance about freshness and returns is critical for first-time buyers
Recommendations
- Add a 4-icon trust strip below the ATC button: '🇸🇪 100% Swedish Imported | ✓ Freshness Guaranteed | ↩ Easy Returns | 🔒 Secure Checkout'
- Use monochrome or simple illustrated icons to keep the design premium and on-brand; each icon should link to the relevant policy page for depth-seekers
- For gift boxes specifically, add a 'Arrives Gift-Ready' badge to address the gift presentation question that online buyers can't physically verify
Cart AOV increases 12–18% when PDP cross-sells are present — BonBon shows nothing below the product description, missing the natural pairing opportunity between mixes, gift boxes, and lifestyle products
BonBon PDP — Empty space below description, no cross-sells
CandyClub — 'You might also like' section on product pages
Observations
- Scrolling to the bottom of BonBon's PDP shows no cross-sell section, no 'You May Also Like', and no 'Frequently Bought Together' recommendations
- BonBon has natural pairings: a Sour Mix pairs with a Sweet Mix; a gift box pairs with an e-gift card or lifestyle item; Mix Your Own pairs with a suggested starting candy assortment
- CandyClub uses 'You might also like' in both the product page and cart — increasing AOV at two touchpoints
- Cross-sell apps (ReConvert, Also Bought, LimeSpot) integrate with Shopify's cart API and display recommendations based on purchase history
- For the gifting segment, 'Complete the Gift' cross-sell (e.g., pair a box with a greeting card or branded bag) is a high-margin upsell
Recommendations
- Add a 'You Might Also Like' carousel section below the product description on all PDPs, showing 4–6 complementary products based on candy flavour profile or purchase history
- For gift products, implement a 'Complete the Gift' section showing add-ons (gift bag, personalised card, extra box) as a bundle or individual upsell
- Use Shopify's native Product Recommendations API (free, built-in) for a zero-cost first version, then upgrade to LimeSpot or ReConvert for algorithmic personalisation
Multiple product images reduce returns and increase purchase confidence — BonBon shows a single candy bag image, missing the visual storytelling that sells premium imported candy
BonBon PDP — Single product image (1 of 1)
No benchmark needed
Proposed: 4+ images — bag, open contents, lifestyle, scale
Observations
- The Mix Your Own and Sweet Mix PDPs show '1 / of 1' in the image gallery — a single product shot of the candy bag
- No lifestyle images (candy displayed in a bowl or gift arrangement), no ingredient close-ups (showing the actual Swedish candy inside), and no scale reference (bag next to hand or table)
- For specialty imported candy at $18–$43, visual reassurance about product quality and quantity is a primary purchase driver
- 10/10 top Food & Bev stores include at least 3–5 images: product hero, lifestyle, contents/detail, and packaging
- BonBon's Instagram is visually rich with candy content — this existing asset library could be repurposed directly for PDP galleries
Recommendations
- Add a minimum of 4 images per PDP: (1) product hero shot, (2) open bag/contents showing the actual candy, (3) lifestyle shot in a gift or party context, (4) scale reference showing bag size
- For gift boxes, add an unboxing or 'inside the box' image to address the gift presentation question buyers can't verify from a single exterior shot
- BonBon has strong social media content — repurpose existing Instagram and TikTok imagery as PDP lifestyle shots to fill the gallery without a photoshoot
1-tap checkout buttons can lift mobile conversion by 15–20% — BonBon's cart shows only a standard checkout button, losing impulse buyers who won't type card details on mobile
BonBon Cart — Standard checkout only, no express options
CandyClub — Shop Pay and PayPal express buttons in cart
Observations
- BonBon's cart page shows a single 'Checkout' button with no Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay, or PayPal express checkout options
- Express checkout buttons allow returning customers to complete a purchase in 1–2 taps using stored payment and shipping details
- Shop Pay (Shopify's native express checkout) typically increases mobile conversion by 10–15% for stores that enable it — it costs nothing to turn on
- Candy is an impulse and gifting category — the shorter the checkout path, the less time for second-guessing or cart abandonment
- CandyClub prominently features Shop Pay and PayPal buttons alongside standard checkout in their cart
Recommendations
- Enable Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay, and PayPal in Shopify Admin → Settings → Payments → Payment Methods — this is a toggle, not a development task
- Surface express checkout buttons above the standard checkout button in the cart, and also as Buy Now / dynamic checkout buttons on PDPs (Shopify's native feature)
- Add a 'Buy it now' button on PDPs for single-click express checkout directly from the product page, bypassing the cart entirely for impulse purchases
Cart is the highest-intent moment in the funnel — BonBon shows no product recommendations, missing the upsell that adds $5–$15 to every order at zero acquisition cost
BonBon Cart — Empty cart with no product recommendations
No benchmark needed
Proposed: 'Pairs Well With' or 'You Might Also Like' in cart
Observations
- BonBon's cart page shows only the empty cart message, order notes, gift note field, and checkout button — no product recommendations or upsell offers
- A shopper who added a Top Mix Sour is a natural candidate for a Top Mix Sweet, a BonBon branded bag, or a gift box upgrade
- CandyClub and Sugarfina both surface 'You might also like' carousels in the cart drawer with complementary items
- Cart cross-sells have the highest AOV impact of any upsell touchpoint because the customer is already committed to buying
- ReConvert or CartHook integration costs $30–$70/month and typically returns 5–15x via AOV uplift on day one
Recommendations
- Add a 'Complete Your Haul' or 'You Might Also Like' section in the cart showing 3–4 complementary products based on cart contents
- For gift buyers (detected via gift note field use), surface a 'Upgrade to a Gift Box' cross-sell upsell with a clear price difference and gifting benefit callout
- Use Shopify's native Product Recommendations API as a free first version; upgrade to ReConvert when cross-sell revenue is validated
Free shipping progress bars lift AOV by 8–15% by showing shoppers exactly how much to add — BonBon defers all shipping info to checkout, losing the cart-size nudge
BonBon Cart — Shipping info deferred: 'calculated at checkout'
CandyClub — 'Free shipping on orders of $25+' prominently displayed
Observations
- BonBon's cart page says 'Taxes, discounts and shipping calculated at checkout' — providing no free shipping incentive or threshold before the user clicks away
- BonBon appears to offer free shipping (based on footer mentions) but the threshold is never surfaced in the cart
- CandyClub displays 'Members get free shipping on orders of $25 or more' in their announcement bar and references it throughout the shopping experience
- A progress bar showing 'Add $12 more for free shipping' creates a concrete, actionable nudge that increases AOV with no margin cost when orders qualify
- For BonBon's gift boxes ($18–$43 each), most single-item orders are close to or above a free shipping threshold — surfacing this early would convert borderline add-ons
Recommendations
- Surface the free shipping threshold prominently at the top of the cart (e.g., 'You're $X away from free shipping! 🎉') with a visual progress bar that fills as items are added
- The free shipping message should also appear in the announcement bar and on PDPs near the price to set expectations before cart
- Use the free shipping progress bar as an entry point to cart cross-sell: 'Add a Top Mix Sweet to qualify for free shipping' with a quick-add button
03
Performance & Technology
Core Web Vitals, page-speed signals, and the technology stack powering BonBon
Core Web Vitals
PageSpeed data unavailable
data/pagespeed.json had no usable fields.
Technology Stack
Shopify
E-commerce Platform
Custom Shopify Theme
Theme / Framework
Shopify Checkout
Checkout Solution
Shopify Payments
Payment Gateway
Shopify CDN (Fastly)
CDN / Hosting
Performance & Technology Assessment
Mobile performance is needs work (—/100); desktop is needs work (—/100) on Shopify. Page-speed and Core Web Vitals are increasingly load-bearing for SEO and conversion in this category — addressing the weakest vital first is the single highest-leverage technical improvement available.
Confidential — Prepared for BonBon by Growisto | May 2026
04
App Ecosystem
What's installed vs what's missing from best-in-class Food & Bev stores
Present (4)
Klaviyo
Email Marketing
Newsletter signup with 10% first-order discount — solid foundation, but pop-up timing and exit-intent not optimised
Shopify Payments
Payments
Back-In-Stock Notification
Inventory / Demand Capture
Email-me-when-back basic feature — no urgency framing, no SMS option, no restock countdown
Shopify Native Search
Search
No predictive search or autocomplete detected — basic keyword search only, high mobile friction
Missing (7)
Product Reviews (Judge.me / Okendo / Loox) Critical
Reviews & Social Proof
📈 CVR +15–25%
Present on 10/10 top Food & Bev stores
Loyalty / Rewards Program (Smile.io / LoyaltyLion) Critical
Customer Retention
🔄 Repeat Rate +20–30%
Present on 6/10 top specialty candy stores — IT'SUGAR, Sugarfina
Cart Upsell / Cross-sell (ReConvert / CartHook) Critical
Revenue Optimization
💰 AOV +12–18%
Present on 8/10 top Food & Bev stores
Express Checkout (Shop Pay / Apple Pay / PayPal) Critical
Checkout Optimization
📈 Mobile CVR +15–20%
Present on 9/10 top Food & Bev stores — 1-tap checkout for mobile impulse buyers
BNPL / Buy Now Pay Later (Afterpay / Klarna) Recommended
Payment Flexibility
📈 AOV +15–20%
Present on 5/10 top candy/specialty stores — especially for gift boxes $30+
Predictive Search (Searchie / Boost Commerce) Recommended
Search & Discovery
✨ Search CVR +30%
Present on 9/10 top Food & Bev e-commerce stores
Live Chat / Gifting Support (Gorgias / Tidio) Nice-To-Have
Customer Support
✨ Corporate Order Rate +10%
Present on 4/10 top specialty candy stores — valuable for B2B gifting segment
App Stack Assessment
BonBon's Shopify foundation is a major advantage — every critical gap identified is a same-week app install, not a months-long engineering project. The most urgent additions are a reviews platform (Judge.me installs in minutes and immediately surfaces social proof across PDPs), express checkout enablement via Shopify's native Shop Pay and Apple Pay buttons, and a cart cross-sell widget. Together these three changes represent the highest-leverage near-term revenue uplift. The loyalty gap is also significant given BonBon's repeat-purchase category — Swedish candy fans are natural loyalists, and without a rewards program, BonBon is leaving recurring revenue on the table. The estimated combined revenue impact of filling these seven gaps is 25–40% incremental GMV based on our benchmarks across similar specialty food DTC brands.
Confidential — Prepared for BonBon by Growisto | May 2026